Five Guys Secret Menu: Patty Melts, In-N-Out-Style Fries and Free Topping Builds
6 min read
The five guys secret menu runs on an open secret: the chain gives away its customization for free. Fifteen toppings cost nothing, extra cheese and extra bacon are famously free too, and the grill crew works an open line where they can see exactly what they are building. The result is a secret menu that is less about hidden items and more about knowing which free combinations produce a different sandwich.
The two headline builds — the Patty Melt and the Double Grilled Cheese Burger — are genuine transformations made entirely from register items. The “In-N-Out-style fries” need an honest explanation, which they get below, along with the topping combinations regulars treat as house specials.
Key Takeaways
- The Patty Melt is a grilled cheese sandwich with a burger patty and grilled onions added — a standard order at any Five Guys.
- The Double Grilled Cheese Burger uses two grilled cheese sandwiches as the bun and is exactly as excessive as it sounds.
- All 15 toppings are free, and extra cheese and extra bacon are free — the economics of building here are unique in fast food.
- “In-N-Out-style fries” at Five Guys means fries loaded with melted cheese, grilled onions, and a mayo-ketchup drizzle you add yourself; there is no secret spread.
- Asking for fries “well done” gets the crispier fry regulars prefer with loaded toppings.
The Headline Builds
The Patty Melt
Order a grilled cheese, add a patty, add grilled onions (and grilled mushrooms if you want the full diner effect). The grilled cheese’s inverted, griddled bun becomes the melt’s crust, the cheese is already molten, and the whole thing eats like a proper patty melt from a lunch counter. Estimated price: $8.50–$10.00 depending on market — the grilled cheese base plus a patty charge, with the onions free.
The Double Grilled Cheese Burger
Order a grilled cheese with a patty, then a second grilled cheese as the top — or, in the phrasing crews know: “a cheeseburger made with two grilled cheese sandwiches as the bun.” Some locations build it as a single order; elsewhere you order two patty melts’ worth of components and stack. Estimated cost: $13.00–$16.00. It is a share item pretending to be a solo order.
The In-N-Out-Style Fries, Honestly
Five Guys has no spread, no Thousand Island, and no animal-style button — so the fan build reconstructs the idea from what exists. Order fries well done, ask for a slice of cheese melted over them where the crew will oblige (or order a side of cheese via a grilled cheese’s worth), add grilled onions, and drizzle the free mayo and ketchup mix from the condiment station. It lands in the same flavor family — crispy potato, molten cheese, sweet grilled onion, tangy sauce — without pretending to be the original. The original itself is covered in our In-N-Out secret menu guide, which is the right place for the real thing. Estimated cost: $6.00–$7.50 with the cheese route, less if you keep it to onions and condiments.
Free Topping Builds Worth Naming
Because all 15 toppings are free, the regulars’ builds are specified by combination rather than by component price. “All the way” is the house standard — lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, ketchup, mustard, and mayo. The “Black and Blue” fan build pairs Cajun seasoning logic with blue-cheese-adjacent creaminess — at Five Guys it means extra grilled onions, mushrooms, and a heavy hand with mayo and hot sauce; there is no blue cheese, so treat the name as poetry. The veggie sandwich with cheese and every grilled topping is the sleeper order: a grilled cheese loaded with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and jalapeños costs an estimated $6.50–$7.50 and eats like a hoagie. And where milkshakes are sold, mixing any two flavors in one cup is a standard ask — bacon in a shake is on the official mix-in list, which tells you everything about this chain.
Five Guys Secret Menu Prices at a Glance
| Build | How to order it | Estimated cost |
|---|---|---|
| Patty Melt | Grilled cheese + patty + grilled onions | $8.50–$10.00 |
| Double Grilled Cheese Burger | Two grilled cheeses as bun + patty | $13.00–$16.00 |
| Loaded fries (“In-N-Out style”) | Fries well done + cheese + grilled onions + mayo-ketchup | $6.00–$7.50 |
| Loaded veggie grilled cheese | Grilled cheese + all grilled toppings | $6.50–$7.50 |
| Extra bacon / extra cheese | Just ask — famously free | $0.00 |
| All the way toppings | Standard phrase at the counter | $0.00 |
The base burger, dog, and fry prices these builds start from are in our Five Guys menu prices 2027 guide.
How to Order at Five Guys
Five Guys is the easiest chain in this series to customize at, because the ordering model is a conversation: you stand at the counter, the toppings list is on the board, and nothing you ask for costs extra except patties. Say the base item, then the build: “grilled cheese, add a patty, add grilled onions.” Watch the fry portion logic too — a regular fries is famously a small mountain, so a loaded-fries build rarely needs the large. And because everything is cooked to order, stacked builds arrive in about the same time as standard ones; there is no rush-hour penalty for creativity here.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I order a Patty Melt at Five Guys?
Ask for a grilled cheese sandwich with a burger patty and grilled onions added. The grilled cheese is a standard menu item, the patty is a simple add-on, and the onions are free.
Are extra bacon and cheese really free at Five Guys?
Yes — that is one of the chain’s best-known policies. Extra cheese and extra bacon carry no charge, and all 15 standard toppings are free as well.
What are In-N-Out-style fries at Five Guys?
A fan reconstruction: well-done fries topped with melted cheese and grilled onions, finished with a mayo-and-ketchup drizzle standing in for spread. Five Guys has no Animal Style; the build borrows the idea, not the recipe.
What does “all the way” mean?
The house combination of eight toppings: lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, ketchup, mustard, and mayonnaise. It is free and it is the default regulars’ order.
How much does the Five Guys secret menu cost?
Most builds cost their base item plus any patty add-on: an estimated $6.50–$10.00 for melts and loaded veggie builds, $13.00–$16.00 for the double grilled cheese burger. Prices vary by location.
What is the best first Five Guys secret order?
The Patty Melt. It is a standard order, it transforms two ordinary items into a diner classic, and the grilled onions are free.
Price Disclaimer
DriveThruPrices.com is an independent guide and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Five Guys. The items above are fan customizations and ordering suggestions, not official menu claims by the chain. Prices are estimated ranges compiled from typical US locations and vary by restaurant and over time. Always check your local restaurant’s current menu for exact pricing.
